Are Field Sobriety Tests Accurate?

Posted by William H. Sherman on Mar 12, 2014 | 0 Comments

Question: I live in Cumming, GA and after work I met a friend at a restaurant in Cumming.  I was driving home and a Forsyth County deputy sheriff stopped me.  He said I was speeding and that my tag light was out.  When I pulled over the cop asked for my driver's license and he asked me if I'd been drinking.  I gave him my license and he told me to get out of the car.  He asked me some questions and then asked me to do some tests.  I think I looked pretty bad on the tests because I hurt my back playing football in college and also in a car accident about two years ago.  I don't think those physical tests are valid because I didn't really have that much to drink.  Can they use those against me in court?

Answer: The tests that you took are known as “field sobriety tests.”  Developed by the National Highway Transportation Safety Administration in Washington, D.C., they are utilized by police departments to attempt to determine if a driver is intoxicated.  The battery of tests that have been sanctioned by NHTSA are:

  1. One-Leg Stand (OLS) test
  2. Walk-and-Turn (WAT) test
  3. Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN) -- eye test

The Forsyth deputy sheriff is supposed to administer the tests properly and then “grade” them.  Grades are provided by the deputy in the form of “clues.”  (A Cumming police officer will administer the same tests when trying to make a DUI arrest.) For instance, on the walk-and-turn test, the deputy may state that he observed 5 of 8 clues.  The amount of clues are alleged to correspond to the driver's level of intoxication.

You wrote that you have back problems.  That could certainly greatly impact your performance on the tests.  (The HGN test, being an eye test, would not, of course, be impacted by a back problem.)  A DUI lawyer would argue that, because of your physical impairment, the OLS and the WAT test should be inadmissible in court or, if they are admitted, that they are of no probative value because of your bad back.  We think it best that a motorist decline to take the field sobriety tests.

We think the tests can make even a sober driver seem impaired, and the tests are not always correctly administered by the police officer.  (A Forsyth deputy and a Cumming police officer will attempt to have a DUI suspect take the field sobriety tests.)

About Us

We at the Sherman Law Group try to answer as many questions as possible on our blog.  If you have a question, email it to us and we'll do our best to answer it.  No names will be used.  Speak to an experienced Cumming and Forsyth County DUI lawyer at the Sherman Law Group by calling 678-215-4106.

About the Author

William H. Sherman

With a professional background that includes serving as a Senior Assistant County Attorney and as an Assistant Attorney General, attorney William H. Sherman has great experience, a broad range of legal knowledge and a proven record of success.  Each of Mr. Sherman's clients gets the full benefit of his experience.  Because attorney Sherman has worked for governmental organizations, large corporations and clerked for a judge, he has handled a wide variety of cases from negotiation and trial to successful appeal. Mr. Sherman is very proud of his reputation as a problem-solver who is always available to his clients.  Active in the community, Mr. Sherman and his wife, attorney Valerie Sherman, support many community organizations, sports teams and charities.  Call him now and let his experience work for you.

Comments

There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

What our clients say...

“I just wanted to write to say that I feel so lucky to have chosen the Sherman Law Group as my attorneys. I was going through such a very difficult legal situation. It was emotionally charged and draining. But Valerie Sherman and Bill Sherman were so supportive, hardworking and helpful. I loved that the firm was always updating me and letting me know what was going on in my case. You always returned my calls and emails. Thank you all for making it work out great for me.”

What our clients say...

“I wanted to thank you for giving me back my life after many awful months. My family and I want to thank you very much for representing my case. We are so grateful to have such wonderful attorneys like you. I know I can rely on you. We will always recommend you to those who are in need of the services of a law firm. We were so happy and excited this morning as we heard the announcement by the Judge. You are such wonderful people at The Sherman Law Group.”